Can our own children teach us a thing or two?

Is spirituality part of your life? I’d like to think that it is part of mine; yet I often fail to acknowledge God’s blessings. And then something happens that reminds me how rich my life is. Most of the times the signs are in the “small fine print” and not in the flashy big screens. Here is an email I rec’d last night from my daughter who’s a medical student. Most of us live by learning from our own experiences but do we also learn from our children lives’ challenges?

“Hello everyone!

I wanted to let all of you know that I love you dearly, and miss you very much! I am at the halfway point of my surgery rotation, and have been trying to keep a log of what’s been going on. To give you an idea of whats been going on during this clerkship, I’ve decided to share with you an excerpt from my log.

“These past few weeks have been very enlightening. I’ve learned much about human kind, myself, and life. Surgery has been an interesting clerkship, not only because it’s been one of the most demanding, but also because it’s given me a lot of insight into the world and culture of medicine.

Today, I spoke with Dr. D, the chief vascular resident on my general surgery rotation at the VA. She is currently in her seventh and last year of surgery residency, and is 37 years old. We spoke a little between seeing patients in clinic, and among the things we talked about, we talked about how an attending made a resident and a medical student cry the other day. She felt bad for both students and thought it was totally unnecessary for an attending to be so rude. She told me that she has changed a lot over the years in residency. Perhaps due to the heartless ways in which the people (esp those high in rank) have treated her, her colleagues, and patients. She has become jaded and trusts people less. She is less naïve about this world, she told me. This made me sad. For multiple reasons. First, it made me sad to think that others can be heartless and so emotionless to not care or be aware of other people’s feelings. Sure, they might be saving someone’s life by taking out an inflamed gallbladder or performing some other incredibly advanced surgical procedure. But if they have no heart, then what good does it really do? How can people be so selfish, heartless, and power hungry to feast off of naïve and caring people who are inspired to do good in this world? Do they realize that they are contributing to a jaded system??? The attending physician has a duty not only to his patients, but also to his students, and if he cannot perform both jobs well, he should choose just the one be does better.

My moral dilemma continues. I see myself torn between having a heart and becoming numb to the painful situations patients are in. Over the past few days, I’ve become attached to patients. I’ve seen them go through pain. I’ve seen a little girl die from being attacked by her own dog. I have seen a 56 year old man mangled by, not one, but two cars. I have seen the results of multiple acts of violence.

During my rotation, I have also seen incredible endovascular operations by very talented and experienced vascular surgeons. I have seen a 79 (!) year old lively, and happy man receive an incredibly complex and risky surgery, and survive! And I think to myself, “wow, he is so resilient.” I wish I could be like that.

What does it take to be resilient like that? Does it take not taking things to heart too much? Or does it mean putting into life all the heart that you have?

Today, we washed a freshly amputated leg of a man who previously had necrotizing fasciitis. My duty was to hold his leg stump up so the resident could see the wound better. The patient was obviously experiencing severe phantom pain as we were washing him. My arms were sore from holding his leg stump in a weird position, and although I was trying to hold his leg up as gently as possible, I couldnt help but feel that I was contributing to his pain, and possibly doing more damage to his leg by putting so much pressure on it with my hands to keep it raised for the resident surgeon. Each scream that came from his mouth made me cringe.

I hurt with the patient. I hurt with the family. IS this a weakness? In a sense it is. It is not too much appreciated in the field of surgery, especially when it interferes with making rational decisions for the patient’s best interest. And I understand that. It makes sense. Surgeons are expected to be tough, stoic, and the surgeon who is able to be level headed and non-emotional during a surgery is the one to be revered. I respect that. And most of the surgeons I’ve worked with are very kind to their patients, even though they do not become involved emotionally. Note: there is a big difference between being kind and becoming involved. Is becoming involved a weakness? On the other spectrum, at what point does stoicism become heartlessness? We, including the physician, are supposed to be human not robots.

Do you ever have a moment, an otherwise perfectly ordinary moment, when you pause and realize that you are truly happy, and for no apparent reason? I do. I have had moments like these in the past. Of course, I have also had moments of sinking despair. But I can honestly say that I have never been more content. With each day, I grow a little wiser. I hope to pass this wisdom on to others. At the same time, I hope to gain wisdom from the people I love, the people that I don’t feel like loving, the moments that shoot me to cloud nine, and the moments that lead me to question my existence.

This life has been a roller coaster so far….a fast one…and I am looking forward (with excitement and I have to admit, a little hesitation!) to the many vertical drops, loops, and figure eights ahead… :-)”

I hope this gives you a little insight into life as a med student…Although I haven’t had too much time to talk with you, I am thinking of you always, and am very blessed to have you all in my life. You inspire me to be better everyday!

Love, Anna”


, , , , , , , , ,

  1. #1 by Guy on January 28, 2011 - 4:36 am

    Thanks for sharing this Carmen! Just the other day I remember praying for a revitalization of my spirituality, and Anna’s letter pretty much nailed it. I’d like to think more people are as compassionate as the both, but unfortunately for all of us, it seems life has a way to periodically numb even our most revered senses through simple repetition. Compassion is often referred to as one of these senses. However, some people that frequently show a lack of compassion probably never had it in the first place. I can’t imagine living life or even walking a mile in someone’s shoes that dismisses the entire concept of compassion for others, and I think we’ve all met some of these helpless people.
    Anna’s letter intrigued me to research a little bit, and I came across an article that I felt compelled to share an excerpt from:
    “Compassion” comes from two Latin words and means “to suffer with.” It is called “the heart of Spirituality” because it recognizes the essential truth that we are all intimately connected. What happens to one of us happens to all of us. To lack Compassion is to lack Spirituality.

    • #2 by carmenalexe on January 29, 2011 - 2:53 am

      That is so profound, Guy, thanks for sharing!

  2. #3 by Wade on January 26, 2011 - 6:06 am

    You (and Anna) hit it out of the park with this one, Carmen. I love the paragraph that starts “Do you ever have a moment…” – talk about spirituality!!!
    Regarding the balance between compassion and objectivity, I have no doubt Anna will be a very caring AND skilled doctor. Ironically there was an excellent article on this exact topic in todays KevinMD blog by Wendy S. Harpham MD entitled “Depersonalization of the patient and loss of compassion”. The link is

  3. #4 by Marolyn Overton on January 25, 2011 - 6:50 pm

    I want your daughter as my doctor when she has finished her education. The best doctors are the ones that care. Let me know where she decides to set up practice. She will be one of the best.
    God Bless,

  4. #5 by Livia Bota on January 25, 2011 - 6:47 pm

    I just love Anna and her letter to you. She’ll be a doctor with a heart, that’s for sure!

  5. #6 by Tanya Sheldon on January 25, 2011 - 6:31 pm

    Honestly it put a tear in my eye. My Niece is a surgeon and her mother (my sister in law) is now in the lowest of lows of her Breast Cancer and Chemo. She has been in the hospital the last three days with everything in her body reacting badly to the 4th and second to last treatment. And poor Lisa with all her medical training can only talk to the doctors taking care of her mother helpless, in knowing what she knows and unable to do anything for her.

  6. #7 by Tom L. on January 25, 2011 - 6:24 pm

    Thanks for sharing Anna’s email. You’re blessed to have such a thoughtful and caring daughter. I’m sure she will resolve any moral dilemmas as she progresses through her medical training and the medical profession and the world will be a better place when she is complete.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: